Explore Catholic mentorship for emotional healing and growth: CatholicPsych’s IDDM, Greg Bottaro’s CPMAP training, other Catholic programs, and how to choose support.
You can identify and even explain the relationship pattern, but you still repeat it.
But you've listened to the Catholic podcasts, learned about healing, and brought the struggle to prayer.
Yet the same argument, fear, or self-criticism returns. Maybe the next step is connecting with a fellow Catholic who helps you work with what you already know.
I am writing up this guide because I have received inquiries about Catholic mentorship with myself (Dr. Lanahan) or my associates (including Vince Deming). We have been inspired by Catholic Psych's model of accompaniment to support some of our clients in a different mode that breaks the mold of traditional therapy, a mode that involves more frequent contact that makes the "container" of support feel more consistent and tangible.
Catholic mentorship offers accompaniment for human formation, emotional, and spiritual growth. Some programs use ongoing voice or written messages. Others offer live conversations, small groups, or structured formation. This guide explains CatholicPsych’s IDDM model, Greg Bottaro’s CPMAP training, and other Catholic resources worth exploring.
A Catholic mentor helps you reflect on your experience, notice recurring patterns, and practice a different response in light of Our Faith. The work may include relationships, boundaries, habits, discernment, and learning to receive love.
Mentorship is distinct from psychotherapy, mental health treatment, crisis support, and emergency care.
A mentor is more accessible, more available and able to give feedback more often than a traditional therapist. However, they are not well-suited for assessing the nature of your problems or giving expert guidance on how to heal the root cause of things.
When you are interested in working with a mentor, it is wise to look into someone’s qualifications. Ask what the mentor has studied, how they receive supervision, and what they do when a concern exceeds their competence.
These days, with the rise of coaching and online services that fall outside of state-regulated professions, it is important to be careful with who you choose to work with. Also, even if you work with a provider who has clinical credentials, it is important to clarify whether they are providing a service that is clinical in nature, or whether it is more like coaching or mentoring.
Asynchronous means you and your mentor communicate at different times. You might record a message after a difficult conversation. Your mentor listens and responds, perhaps not right away, but within a reasonable time frame.
Imagine this: you agree to something you resent, then criticize yourself for being weak. A mentoring conversation might help you notice what you feared would happen if you said no, put that fear into words, and prepare a gameplan for how to say 'no' to the next boundary-crossing request.
Want support that connects faith with everyday life?
Explore Catholic mentorship with Insight Anchors →
Tell us what you hope to work on and ask about availability, format, and fit.
If you searched for “Catholic Psych mentorship” or “Greg Bottaro mentoring,” you likely encountered the CatholicPsych Institute. Founded by Catholic psychologist Dr. Gregory Bottaro, it offers IDDM: Integrated Daily Dialogic Mentorship.
CatholicPsych describes IDDM as psychologically informed accompaniment grounded in a Catholic understanding of the person. Its published format uses recorded messages through an app, with mentor responses Monday through Friday, generally within 24 hours. Its guidelines ask participants to keep messages between responses to about 15 minutes.
For readers comparing Catholic therapy and daily mentorship, the important questions are practical: who accompanies you, what their preparation includes, and what happens if you need clinical care. Read the provider’s service agreement as well as its promotional page.
Explore CatholicPsych’s mentorship model and review its service terms. These describe the approach and the terms, which would be wise to read carefully, since some of the offerings are non-refundable.
In addition to mentoring, I have had inquiries about Catholic Psych's homegrown curriculum for developing mentors.
CPMAP stands for the CatholicPsych Model of Applied Personalism. It brings Catholic anthropology, spirituality, and psychology into a semi-structured online formation program.
CatholicPsych’s current introductory level, Encounter, is a six-month course with weekly meetings led by a director. Its published pathway distinguishes the Formation Track from a separate Partner Track for paid accompaniment. The latter involves an application and supervised client practice at later levels.
An important distinction you need to understand if you want to become a Catholic mentor: personal formation vs. professional preparation/certification. Becoming a Catholic mentor through Dr. Bottaro's program does not confer a professional certification or a mental health license. But it does offer a set, designed program that can help you reflect on what it means to integrate the Catholic worldview with helping others from three lenses: philosophy, theology/spirituality, and psychology. I believe it involves a lot of reading excerpts from various sources within these three fields, then writing a reflection that integrates all three sources. These programs simulate graduate level classes with prompts for writing reflection articles, without the pressure of grades.
There are other programs that could be considered Catholic mentoring that do not involve recorded messages as the sole source of communication.
Souls & Hearts, co-founded by Dr. Peter Malinoski and Dr. Gerry Crete, offers Catholic psychological resources. Its Resilient Catholics Community combines structured human formation, small groups, and companion support, informed by Internal Family Systems within a Catholic framework. The community explicitly distinguishes its work from therapy.
For those who accompany others, its Formation for Formators offers opportunities to work on their own human formation. These are community and formation options rather than the same service as individual daily mentorship.
The John Paul II Healing Center offers retreats and resources associated with Dr. Bob Schuchts and Sr. Miriam James Heidland. Its Healing the Whole Person online course provides recorded teaching, reflections, and prayer resources to engage at your own pace.
A self-paced course may give you a framework and language for your experience. Personal mentoring adds a relationship in which you can explore how that material applies to you. A course purchase alone does not provide that ongoing relationship.
Therapy, mentoring, and spiritual direction can complement one another. Catholic therapy provides clinical care for psychological and relational difficulties, while spiritual direction focuses on prayer, discernment, and your relationship with God. Catholic mentoring offers faith-informed accompaniment for personal and emotional growth, with practical support for everyday life rather than clinical treatment.
No. “Asynchronous counseling” may describe clinical services delivered through messages, while asynchronous mentoring describes a communication format for accompaniment. However, licensed therapists can provide mentoring/coaching aside from their clinical counseling modality, so it is wise to ask them to be clear on the intended service.
I have a special compassion for those who have felt called to put out content to their fellow Catholics, and in fact they put out very good content, that is edifying and transformative for others. However, with being in the public eye, they have more pressure to be a certain way or to practice what they preach.
For Catholic content creators, ministry leaders, and people who consume a great deal of formation content, a useful question is: Where am I practicing what I teach or learn—and who helps me see what I miss?
Mentoring gives what you are teaching/learning somewhere to take root: a relationship where you can be honest.
For related reading, explore our guides to Souls & Hearts resources and Sr. Miriam James’s Loved As I Am
Ready to move from understanding the pattern to working on it?
Find your next step with Insight Anchors →
Use the contact form to ask about Catholic mentorship, emotional growth, or whether therapy may better fit your needs.
Independent resource guide from Insight Anchors. Mentioning a program does not imply affiliation, endorsement, or certification by that organization. Program descriptions were checked in November 2026; confirm current details with each provider.